What Does the Jury Look for in Sex Crime Cases

Sex crime cases are a serious allegation and justice is imperative for such a situation. With that in mind, what does the jury use to determine guilt or innocence? What should a defendant consider regarding this?

Today, we will share information regarding an important question: What does the jury look for in sex crime cases?

JD Solicitors are a fully (SRA) regulated law firm with a team of highly qualified and specialist solicitors. Our solicitors recognise that being investigated or charged with a serious criminal offence is a daunting prospect.

Our specialist advice and reassurance, from the first phone call through to the conclusion of the case, is the bare minimum of what we offer when it comes to our clients.

How are jurors picked?

Jurors are selected randomly from the electoral register. This ensures a diverse pool of potential jurors from various backgrounds. Once selected, individuals receive a summons to attend court.

A jury typically consists of 12 people. Before the trial begins, both the prosecution and the defence may challenge potential jurors. This process, known as jury vetting, can involve questioning potential jurors about their backgrounds and beliefs to ensure impartiality.

It’s important to note that jury service is a civic duty, and it’s crucial to be impartial and to base decisions solely on the evidence presented in court.

Can a juror personally know anyone in the case?

No, a juror should not personally know anyone involved in the case. This includes the defendant, the victim, any witnesses, or the legal teams.

If a juror realises they know someone involved, they must disclose this information to the judge immediately. This is crucial to ensure a fair and impartial trial. The judge may then decide to excuse the juror from the case.

It’s important for jurors to remain impartial and base their decision solely on the evidence presented in court. Any personal relationships or biases could compromise the fairness of the trial.

What if a juror doesn’t disclose a personal connection?

If a juror fails to disclose a connection to someone involved in the case, it can have serious consequences. A juror’s failure to disclose such information is considered contempt of court, which is a serious offence. It can lead to a range of penalties, including:

Retrial: The judge may declare a mistrial if they believe the juror’s undisclosed connection has compromised the fairness of the trial.
Legal Action: The juror may face legal action, including fines or even imprisonment.
Damage to the Legal System: Such actions can erode public trust in the justice system and undermine the integrity of legal proceedings.

It’s crucial for jurors to be honest and transparent about any potential conflicts of interest. By doing so, they help ensure a fair and just trial for all parties involved.

What does the jury look for in sex crime cases?

When a jury deliberates on a sex crime case, they carefully weigh a few key factors. These factors include the credibility of witnesses, the consistency of statements, supporting evidence, the defendant’s behaviour, and the legal guidance provided by the judge.

Credibility of witnesses

A significant factor in a sex crime case is the credibility of the witnesses. The jury will assess the witness’s consistency, are their statements consistent across their testimonies? Are the accounts in detail? Are they clear and coherent?

Jury members also take note of emotional responses, are they natural? Excessive? Inconsistent? Do they lack emotion entirely? Adding to this is a witness’s demeanour. Although this isn’t an exact indication of guilt, truth, or innocence, it can give an insight into a witness’s general character, which could help to inform the jury’s understanding of them.

Consistency of statements

Any inconsistencies in a witness’s statements can significantly weaken their credibility. The jury will examine whether the witness provides reasonable explanations for any discrepancies.

Supporting evidence

Supporting evidence can strengthen a case. This may include physical evidence, forensic evidence such as DNA, fingerprints, CCTV or medical records. Witness testimony, which includes corroborating evidence from other witnesses. As well as documentary evidence, including text messages, emails, or social media posts.

Defendant’s general behaviour

The defendant’s behaviour during the trial can also influence the jury’s perception. Factors such as the plausibility of their alibi and their demeanour on the stand can be crucial.

Legal Guidance

The judge provides the jury with legal instructions, including the burden of proof. In the UK, the prosecution must prove guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

Guidance for Defendants

Defendants in sex crime cases should:

Seek Legal Representation: Consult with an experienced solicitor.
Be Honest: While honesty is crucial, it’s important to avoid self-incrimination. A well-versed solicitor will inform you the dos and don’ts of what to do if you find yourself in a legal situation.
Maintain a Calm Demeanour: A calm and composed demeanour can project innocence. Behaving erratically and disrespectfully will not help your case whatsoever.
Trust in Legal Counsel: Rely on the advice of your solicitor.
Respect the Legal Process: Show respect for the court, judge, jury, and witnesses.

By understanding these factors and seeking appropriate legal counsel, defendants can navigate the complex legal process and protect their rights.

Do juries need a unanimous decision?

No, in the UK, juries are not required to reach a unanimous verdict. In certain circumstances, a majority verdict can be accepted. However, the specific requirements for a majority verdict depend on the number of jurors remaining on the panel.

For example, if a jury is reduced to 11 members, a majority verdict of 10 to 1 is acceptable. If there are 10 jurors, a majority of 9 is required. If a unanimous verdict cannot be reached and a majority verdict is not yet permissible, the jury may be discharged, and a retrial may be ordered.

This is why defendants must present themselves in the best possible light, with evidence, a respectful and responsive demeanour, as well as clarity when they communicate.

Willenhall HQ:

J D Solicitors, Malthouse Chambers,

30 Walsall St,

Willenhall,

WV13 2ER

Birmingham Office:

J D Solicitors, Room 16, Apex House,

Calthorpe Road,

Birmingham

B15 1TR

Stourbridge Office:

J D Solicitors,

Union Street,

Stourbridge,

DY8 1PR

Emergency Assistance Outside Office Hours?

For immediate advice, call us at 01902 943726.

Emergency Assistance Outside Office Hours?

If you require legal help outside our regular business hours, don’t hesitate to call our emergency line at 07971 194042.

We’re here for you, every step of the way.